You just inherited a retirement account. The balance looks substantial—maybe it’s more money than you’ve ever seen in one place. Your first instinct might be to take the cash and run.
I get it. That impulse feels natural.
But here’s what most people don’t realize until it’s too late: cashing out early could be one of the most expensive financial decisions you’ll ever make.
The Quick Money Trap
When you withdraw from an inherited retirement account before age 59½, the money doesn’t just disappear from your account. It triggers immediate tax consequences that could take a significant bite—potentially 30% to 40% depending on your tax bracket and state.
That $100,000 inheritance? It might become $60,000 or $70,000 after taxes. Sometimes less.
The money arrives. You spend it on a car, a down payment, or paying off debt. And within a few years, it’s gone. What seemed like a windfall becomes a memory.
This happens more often than you’d think.
The Hidden Cost: What You Give Up
But the tax hit isn’t the worst part. The real damage is what financial professionals call opportunity cost—the future growth you sacrifice by pulling money out today.
Consider what happens when you cash out an inherited account versus leaving it invested. If you withdraw $100,000 immediately, you might walk away with $65,000 after taxes and penalties.
Now consider the alternative. If that $100,000 remains invested and grows at a 7% annually over 30 years, that account could be worth over $760,000. Over 35 years, it could exceed $1 million.
The difference between $65,000 now and $1 million later isn’t luck. It’s the power of compound growth—and the patience to let it work.
How Compounding Actually Works
Compound growth might sound like financial jargon, but the concept is straightforward. Your money earns returns. Those returns generate their own returns. And the cycle continues, year after year.
In the first few years, the growth feels modest. But time amplifies the effect. The longer your money remains invested, the more dramatic the results become.
Think of it like planting a tree. You don’t dig it up every few months to check the roots. You water it, give it sunlight, and let nature do its work. Twenty years later, you have shade.
Your inherited account works the same way. Leave it alone, and it could grow into something far more valuable than the initial balance suggests.
When Patience Pays Off
The tension between immediate gratification and long-term security is real. The money feels tangible. The future feels abstract.
This is where the math becomes revealing. A $200,000 inheritance withdrawn at age 28 might net roughly $130,000 after taxes. That amount could cover a substantial down payment or eliminate student debt.
But that same $200,000 left invested until age 60 could grow to approximately $1.5 million at a 7% annual return. By age 65, it could approach $2.1 million.
The question becomes: what’s worth more? The immediate use of $130,000, or the potential security of $2 million in retirement?
There’s no universal right answer. But it’s worth considering what you’re trading away.
You Have Options
If you’ve inherited a retirement account, you don’t have to choose between cashing out or doing nothing. Several strategies could help you manage the inheritance while minimizing tax consequences and preserving long-term growth.
You might consider:
-
- For Spouses only:
-
- Stretching distributions over your lifetime to reduce annual tax impact
-
- Rolling the account into an inherited IRA with more flexible withdrawal rules
-
- For Spouses only:
-
- For all:
-
- Taking strategic partial withdrawals only when necessary
-
- Coordinating distributions with your overall tax planning
-
- For all:
Each approach depends on your specific situation—your age, income, goals, and the type of account you inherited.
Some people find that taking a smaller, strategic withdrawal for an immediate need while leaving the majority invested offers a middle path. Others discover that restructuring how they think about existing debt or savings allows them to preserve the inheritance entirely.
The point isn’t to never touch the money. It’s to understand the full cost of your decision before you make it.
Why This Matters Now
You’re at a stage in life where time is your greatest advantage. The decisions you make today with an inherited account could shape your financial future for decades.
This isn’t about restricting access to your own money. It’s about understanding what you’re giving up when you withdraw it early—and making an informed choice with your eyes open.
The younger you are when you inherit, the more powerful compound growth becomes. Each decade you leave the money invested could potentially double or triple its value, depending on market conditions and investment strategy.
About Me and Measured Financial
As a Financial Advisor, it’s my mission to build a client relationship that goes beyond financial investment. I’m committed to putting my clients first by building relationships and providing value from day one. It’s not an investment in securities alone. It begins with an investment in trust.
At Measured Financial, our expertise is to broaden your investment opportunities through investments not dependent on the whims of the stock market. You’re treated with a personal touch, and we strive for you to feel valued, heard, and understood every time we interact with you. We take your trust seriously. That’s why we’re straightforward, honest, and open in our communication.
If you’ve inherited a retirement account and you’re not sure what to do next, let’s talk. Visit https://www.measuredfinancial.com/contact-page-alex-gibbs/, fill out the contact form, and a human will call you to schedule a discussion. We’ll walk through your options together—no pressure, just clarity.
